Autism Isn't Replacing Mental Health. We're Failing to Recognise Both.

Why the conversation about rising autism diagnoses is missing a much bigger problem.
By Amy Dalwood-Fairbanks
Paediatric Clinical Hypnotherapist, Neurodiversity Family Coach and Founder of Magic Minds Family Hypnotherapy
A recent social media post by psychologist Dr Naomi Fisher, discussing research into adult autism diagnoses, has prompted considerable debate within the neurodivergent community. The research examines changes in the characteristics and clinical histories of adults receiving autism diagnoses in Sweden and the UK. According to Fisher's summary, adults diagnosed with autism historically had higher rates of epilepsy, intellectual disability or psychotic disorders, while those receiving diagnoses more recently are more likely to have histories of anxiety, depression, ADHD and emotional distress.
Fisher suggests that difficulties previously understood as psychological or emotional are increasingly being interpreted through a neurodevelopmental lens. She raises an important concern: if we explain distress through autism, a lifelong neurodevelopmental difference, do we risk taking away people's hope of recovery? I understand the concern about overlooking treatable mental health conditions, and it is something we should all take seriously.
However, I believe this interpretation overlooks something fundamental. What if these people aren't being diagnosed with autism instead of mental health difficulties? What if they've been living with both, and we've spent years failing to recognise the relationship between them?
That is the conversation I believe we desperately need to be having.
Autism and Mental Health Are Not Competing Explanations

Autism is a lifelong neurodevelopmental difference, not a mental health condition. Yet autistic people can, and frequently do, experience anxiety, depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), trauma-related difficulties and other significant mental health conditions. These difficulties are neither inevitable nor simply part of being autistic, and they deserve the same attention, assessment and appropriate treatment as they would in anyone else. Unfortunately, this distinction is not always well understood within the services responsible for providing support.
A major systematic review and meta-analysis published in The Lancet Psychiatry by Lai and colleagues (2019) examined the prevalence of co-occurring mental health diagnoses among autistic people. The review found that psychiatric conditions, including anxiety and depression, frequently coexist with autism, although reported prevalence varies considerably between studies. This is important evidence because it challenges the assumption that identifying autism somehow replaces the need to investigate mental health difficulties. In fact, NICE guidance for autistic children and young people (CG170) explicitly recommends that they have full access to mental health services, regardless of intellectual ability or coexisting diagnoses, and recognises the importance of identifying and treating co-occurring mental health conditions.
We should not have to choose between recognising someone's neurodivergence and supporting their mental health. Both can be true, both can require understanding, and both need to inform the support we provide. The problem arises when we treat these as competing explanations rather than recognising that they can coexist and influence one another.
When Mental Health Diagnoses Obscure Neurodivergence
For decades, many neurodivergent people, particularly women and girls, have experienced years of mental health difficulties before anyone considers whether they might be autistic or have ADHD. They may have received diagnoses of anxiety, depression or other psychiatric conditions, attended counselling, completed courses of therapy, taken medication and repeatedly been encouraged to change their thinking, manage their reactions or develop greater resilience. Some of that support may have been helpful, but what if nobody ever asked why they were struggling in the first place?
What if their anxiety was connected to years of masking? What if their depression developed alongside prolonged exhaustion from trying to meet expectations that were fundamentally incompatible with their needs? What if their emotional distress reflected chronic sensory overload, social exhaustion, repeated experiences of rejection or a lifetime of feeling different without understanding why? These are not reasons to dismiss mental health diagnoses, but they are essential considerations if we want to understand the origins and maintenance of someone's distress.
Research by Hull and colleagues (2017) explored the experiences of 92 autistic adults who camouflage or mask their autistic characteristics in social situations. Participants described the significant effort involved in appearing neurotypical, including exhaustion and negative effects on their sense of self. Although this qualitative research does not establish that masking directly causes mental health conditions, it highlights the emotional demands of navigating a world that does not consistently accommodate neurodivergent differences. When those demands go unrecognised, we risk treating the resulting distress without addressing the circumstances that may be contributing to it.
Imagine spending years being told that you have an anxiety disorder while nobody recognises that you're autistic and constantly overwhelmed by sensory environments, social expectations and the exhausting effort of appearing to cope. You might receive treatment designed to help you tolerate situations that are genuinely overwhelming, or learn strategies for challenging anxious thoughts without anyone considering whether the environment itself needs to change. You might become increasingly convinced that you're failing at recovery, when in reality the support you've received has never fully accounted for your needs.
Then, years later, you receive an autism diagnosis. Suddenly, there is another way to understand your experiences, not because the anxiety wasn't real, but because the anxiety was never the whole story. Recognising autism doesn't replace a mental health diagnosis; it provides essential context. It may help explain why certain difficulties developed, why conventional interventions haven't worked, and what needs to change to support meaningful recovery. An autism diagnosis doesn't remove the possibility of recovery. It can provide the understanding that makes recovery more achievable.
When Autism Obscures Mental Health Difficulties
However, there is another side to this problem, and it is one that particularly concerns me. While some neurodivergent people spend years having their autism overlooked because professionals focus exclusively on their mental health, others experience the reverse. Their mental health difficulties are overlooked, minimised or attributed entirely to their autism, sometimes with devastating consequences.
An autistic child who becomes increasingly withdrawn may be told that this is simply how autistic children behave. A young person who develops overwhelming anxiety may have their distress explained away as part of their autism. A child experiencing intrusive thoughts and compulsive behaviours may have those difficulties mistaken for autistic routines or repetitive behaviours, without anyone investigating whether they could be experiencing OCD. Similarly, when a young person loses the ability to manage everyday activities, withdraws from relationships or becomes increasingly distressed, their difficulties may be described as challenging behaviour, avoidance or an inevitable consequence of their diagnosis, rather than prompting a comprehensive assessment of what has changed.
This is known as diagnostic overshadowing, a phenomenon in which an existing diagnosis leads professionals to overlook or misattribute other difficulties. It is particularly concerning when autism and mental health conditions share outwardly similar presentations. Repetitive behaviours associated with autism can sometimes resemble compulsions associated with OCD, yet the underlying experiences and reasons for those behaviours may be very different. Similarly, withdrawal and reduced engagement might reflect autistic burnout, depression, anxiety, sensory overwhelm or several overlapping difficulties. We cannot reliably distinguish between these possibilities simply by observing behaviour. We need to understand the person's experiences, their developmental history, what has changed and what is happening in their environment.
NICE guidance (CG170) specifically recommends assessing coexisting mental health conditions, including anxiety and depression, when autistic children and young people experience behaviours that challenge. This recognises that behaviour alone does not tell us what is happening underneath. Yet in practice, families can still find themselves fighting to have these possibilities properly investigated.
The consequences of diagnostic overshadowing can be significant in either direction. Autism can be missed because someone has a mental health diagnosis, and mental health conditions can be missed because someone is autistic. Either way, the individual falls through the cracks.
The Human Cost of Getting It Wrong
I am neurotypical, but I am also a parent of neurodivergent children and a specialist paediatric clinical hypnotherapist who works with neurodivergent children, young people and their families. I don't claim to speak for autistic people or to understand their lived experience from the inside. However, I have spent years listening, observing, learning and witnessing what happens when neurodivergent people are misunderstood by systems that are supposed to support them.
I have seen the consequences within my own family. I have witnessed what happens when mental health difficulties are misunderstood because neurodivergence hasn't been recognised, and I've seen the other side, when significant mental health difficulties are dismissed or inadequately addressed because autism is already part of the picture. The impact can be devastating, not just for the individual, but for their entire family. These are not abstract diagnostic debates when you are living with the consequences of professionals failing to recognise what is happening.
Through my work, I have also supported families whose children have become so overwhelmed that everyday life has gradually become smaller and smaller. Some can no longer attend school, while others struggle to leave their bedrooms or engage in activities they once enjoyed. They may be experiencing intense anxiety, shutdown, compulsive behaviours or profound emotional exhaustion, yet their families frequently find themselves caught between services that seem unable to address the whole picture.
Mental health professionals may lack sufficient understanding of neurodivergence, while autism services may focus on assessment and diagnosis without providing ongoing mental health support. Schools may interpret distress as behavioural non-compliance, and parents are left trying to navigate fragmented systems while watching their child struggle. What concerns me most is that we can become so focused on identifying which diagnostic category someone belongs to that we lose sight of the person experiencing the distress.
Surely the most important question shouldn't be whether a child is autistic or experiencing mental health difficulties. It should be: What is happening for this child, what is contributing to their distress, and what support will genuinely help?
Recovery Does Not Mean Becoming Less Autistic
One of the most troubling implications of the original discussion is the suggestion that recognising autism as lifelong might somehow create hopelessness about change. However, this depends entirely on what we mean by change. If the goal is to make an autistic person less autistic, then that is fundamentally misguided. Autism is not an illness to be cured. But if the goal is to reduce distress, support emotional wellbeing, rebuild capacity, develop confidence, improve quality of life and help someone feel safer in their world, then recognising autism is not a barrier. It is often essential.
There is research demonstrating the effectiveness of appropriately adapted mental health treatment. A randomised clinical trial published in JAMA Psychiatry by Wood and colleagues (2020) investigated cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) for anxiety in 167 autistic children. The study compared autism-adapted CBT, standard CBT and treatment as usual. Both CBT approaches demonstrated benefits, but the autism-adapted intervention produced significantly greater reductions in anxiety on the study's primary outcome measure.
This finding is important because it demonstrates that recognising autism and treating co-occurring mental health difficulties are entirely compatible. Indeed, adapting treatment to account for autistic needs can improve outcomes. The particular intervention studied included behavioural and social-communication components, so its findings should not automatically be generalised to every form of neurodiversity-informed therapy. Nevertheless, the broader principle is significant: recognising neurological differences does not prevent psychological change. It can help us understand how to support that change more effectively.
An autistic person can recover from depression without becoming less autistic. They can receive effective treatment for OCD without having their autistic needs dismissed, and they can develop ways to manage anxiety that respect their sensory profile, communication preferences and processing differences. Someone experiencing autistic burnout may gradually rebuild their capacity through appropriate support and changes to the demands placed upon them. Recovery may not look like a return to how things were before; sometimes it means creating a different way forward, one that respects the person's neurology rather than continually expecting them to adapt to an environment that overwhelms them.
Recovery should never be measured by how successfully someone can appear neurotypical. It should be measured by improvements in their wellbeing, autonomy, capacity and ability to live a life that feels meaningful to them.
Understanding Autistic Burnout and Its Relationship with Mental Health
Autistic burnout adds another important dimension to this conversation. Research by Raymaker and colleagues (2020), published in Autism in Adulthood, explored autistic adults' experiences of burnout. Participants described profound exhaustion, loss of previously available skills and reduced tolerance to everyday stimuli. Their accounts highlighted the cumulative impact of prolonged demands, masking and insufficient support. Although this research was exploratory and does not establish a universally agreed clinical definition or a proven treatment pathway, it provides valuable insight into experiences that have historically received limited attention within conventional mental health services.
Consider what might happen when an autistic person experiencing burnout is assessed by a professional who doesn't recognise it. Their exhaustion might be interpreted as depression, their withdrawal as avoidance, and their reduced capacity as a lack of motivation. Their inability to attend school or work might be interpreted as anxiety that needs to be overcome through increasing exposure. Yet what if the person's capacity is already overwhelmed by demands? What if the immediate priority needs to be reducing those demands, addressing unmet needs and creating conditions in which recovery becomes possible?
This doesn't mean that every autistic person experiencing burnout should avoid psychological treatment, nor does it mean that depression, anxiety or other mental health conditions should be dismissed as burnout. In fact, these difficulties may coexist. The point is that we need to understand what is happening before deciding what support is appropriate. An intervention that is helpful for one person may be unsuitable, inaccessible or overwhelming for another, and if we misunderstand the nature of someone's distress, we risk recommending support that fails to address their needs.
The distinction between neurological differences, environmental pressures, burnout and co-occurring mental health conditions is not always straightforward. However, that complexity is precisely why comprehensive, neurodiversity-informed assessment matters. We need to understand the individual rather than simply attaching a label to the symptoms we can see.
The Missing Piece: Neurodiversity-Informed Mental Health Support
This is where I believe the greatest gap lies. Many mental health services have developed around assumptions about how people communicate, process emotions, engage in therapy and respond to interventions. Traditional therapeutic approaches may expect individuals to identify and verbalise feelings, sustain eye contact, answer direct questions, reflect on abstract concepts or engage in emotionally demanding conversations. For some neurodivergent people, these expectations can themselves create significant distress, making it difficult to access the very support intended to help them.
That doesn't mean therapy cannot work. It means therapy needs to adapt, and importantly, this is not simply an alternative therapeutic philosophy. It is recognised within established clinical guidance. NICE guideline CG142 recommends adaptations to psychological interventions for autistic adults with coexisting mental health conditions, including more concrete and structured approaches, written or visual information, reduced ambiguity, breaks and consideration of individual interests and communication needs. NICE guideline CG170 similarly recommends adjustments to the physical environment and processes of care for autistic children and young people, alongside appropriate treatment for coexisting mental health conditions.
The principle is clear: effective mental health support must recognise and accommodate neurodevelopmental differences rather than ignore them. We need professionals who understand how autism and ADHD can influence the presentation of anxiety, depression, OCD, trauma and other mental health difficulties. We need clinicians who can distinguish between autistic characteristics, burnout, co-occurring mental health conditions and the effects of prolonged environmental stress. We need approaches that account for sensory needs, communication differences, demand sensitivity, processing time and individual capacity, rather than assuming that a therapeutic approach is appropriate for everyone simply because it has been effective for a particular population.
Evidence-based care remains essential, but so does understanding whom the evidence represents, how interventions can be adapted and whether the individual can meaningfully access and engage with them. At Magic Minds, my work centres on low-demand, indirect therapeutic support, nervous-system safety and helping families rebuild connection and capacity. This isn't about replacing specialist mental health treatment when it is needed; it's about recognising that support must be accessible to the person receiving it.
Sometimes that means working through stories rather than direct questioning. Sometimes it means supporting parents to create a calmer, more predictable environment, or reducing expectations and allowing recovery to begin at home. At other times, it means recognising that a child needs specialist assessment or treatment for a mental health condition alongside autism-informed support. These approaches should always be considered according to individual needs, professional competence and the available evidence. Research supporting adapted CBT, for example, cannot be taken as direct proof of the effectiveness of every low-demand or indirect therapeutic method.
There is no single approach that will meet every neurodivergent person's needs. However, there is one principle that should underpin all of them: we must adapt our support to the individual, rather than expecting the individual to adapt to our support.
Are We Asking the Wrong Question About Rising Autism Diagnoses?
The increase in adult autism diagnoses deserves careful research and thoughtful discussion. Diagnostic criteria, awareness, referral patterns and the populations being assessed have changed over time, and understanding those changes matters. Fisher is right to raise questions about the implications of how we conceptualise psychological distress. We should absolutely be concerned if treatable mental health conditions are being overlooked because someone has received an autism diagnosis, but we should be equally concerned if autism is being overlooked because someone has received a mental health diagnosis. These are not opposing concerns; they are two sides of the same problem.
A change in the clinical histories of people receiving autism diagnoses does not, by itself, establish that autism is being diagnosed instead of mental health conditions. Nor does it tell us whether those individuals have been accurately diagnosed, previously misdiagnosed or experiencing co-occurring conditions. Those are separate questions requiring further investigation, and we must be careful not to imply that people with anxiety, depression or emotional distress are somehow less legitimately autistic than those whose presentations were more commonly recognised in previous decades.
Autism has never been a single, uniform experience, and the people who were most readily identified historically do not necessarily represent the full diversity of autistic people who have always existed. For many adults, receiving a diagnosis isn't about being given a new identity or an excuse not to change; it's about finally understanding a lifetime of experiences that previously made little sense. That understanding can create opportunities for appropriate support, self-acceptance and recovery, but diagnosis alone is not enough.
Which brings me to the question I think we should really be asking: what happens after the diagnosis?
What Happens After the Diagnosis?
We spend enormous amounts of time debating who should receive an autism diagnosis, why diagnosis rates are increasing and what autism should mean. Meanwhile, countless neurodivergent children, young people and adults are struggling to access mental health support that genuinely understands their needs. Some have spent years receiving treatment that didn't recognise their neurodivergence, while others are denied meaningful mental health support because their difficulties are assumed to be part of their autism. Many are passed between services that operate in isolation from one another, and families are left trying to make sense of it all.
This is precisely why I am writing my book, Falling Through the Cracks. I believe one of the most urgent issues facing neurodivergent people isn't simply whether we are diagnosing too many or too few. It's whether we are actually understanding and supporting the people behind those diagnoses. It's about recognising mental health difficulties when they coexist with neurodivergence, identifying neurodivergence when it has been obscured by years of emotional distress, and creating services capable of understanding both.
I don't want a world where autistic people are told that their distress is simply something they must live with because they are wired differently. But I equally don't want a world where their distress is treated without recognising the neurological differences, environmental pressures and unmet needs that may be contributing to it. Neither approach is good enough.
We need mental health professionals who understand neurodivergence, neurodevelopmental services that recognise mental health needs, and greater collaboration between professionals, families and neurodivergent people themselves. Above all, we need to move beyond the assumption that understanding someone's neurology and supporting their psychological wellbeing are somehow competing objectives.
Autism doesn't cancel out mental health difficulties. And mental health difficulties don't cancel out autism.
Until our systems can recognise and respond to both, neurodivergent people will continue to fall through the cracks. And that, rather than the rising number of autism diagnoses alone, is where I believe our attention urgently needs to be focused.
Because the failure isn't in recognising neurodivergence. It's in failing to recognise the whole person.
References
Hull, L., Petrides, K. V., Allison, C., et al. (2017). “Putting on My Best Normal”: Social Camouflaging in Adults with Autism Spectrum Conditions. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 47, 2519–2534.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-017-3166-5
Lai, M.-C., Kassee, C., Besney, R., et al. (2019). Prevalence of co-occurring mental health diagnoses in the autism population: A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet Psychiatry, 6(10), 819–829.https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(19)30289-5
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2012, updated 2021). Autism spectrum disorder in adults: Diagnosis and management. Clinical guideline CG142.https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg142
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2013, updated 2021). Autism spectrum disorder in under 19s: Support and management. Clinical guideline CG170.https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg170
Raymaker, D. M., Teo, A. R., Steckler, N. A., et al. (2020). “Having All of Your Internal Resources Exhausted Beyond Measure and Being Left with No Clean-Up Crew”: Defining Autistic Burnout. Autism in Adulthood, 2(2), 132–143.https://doi.org/10.1089/aut.2019.0079
Wood, J. J., Kendall, P. C., Wood, K. S., et al. (2020). Cognitive Behavioral Treatments for Anxiety in Children With Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Psychiatry, 77(5), 474–483.https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2019.4160
Original research discussed by Dr Naomi Fisher: BMJ Mental Health, volume 29, article e302983 (2026).https://mentalhealth.bmj.com/content/29/1/e302983
About the author
Amy Dalwood-Fairbanks is an award-winning specialist paediatric clinical hypnotherapist, neurodiversity family coach and former primary school teacher, with over 20 years' experience working with children and young people.
She is the founder of Magic Minds Family Hypnotherapy and a mother of two autistic children. Her work focuses on helping neurodivergent children and their families move from overwhelm, withdrawal and school attendance difficulties towards greater safety, connection and capacity through low-demand, parent-led therapeutic support.
Amy is an international speaker and co-author of the bestselling book Children's Mental Health Matters, in which she contributed the chapter When School Feels Impossible.



Comments